Contents
Allwell Papers on PhilanthropyNo. 04

For individuals & families

Donor-Advised Fund, Private Foundation, or Direct Giving?

Allwell · Philanthropy Advisory

Abstract

How to choose the right vehicle for your generosity.

One of the most common questions we hear is "How should I give?" It's a good question, but it usually comes second. The vehicle should serve your purpose, not the other way around. Once you know what you want to accomplish, choosing the structure gets much easier.

Here's a plain-English overview of the three most common options.

Direct giving

Writing a check, giving online, or transferring stock straight to a charity. It's simple, immediate, and personal. There's no setup and no fees. The tradeoff is that there's no structure: no central record, no way to set money aside now and decide later, and no easy way to involve family.

Donor-advised fund (DAF)

A charitable account held by a sponsoring organization, such as a community foundation or the charitable arm of a financial firm. You contribute assets, take a tax deduction in the year you give, and recommend grants over time. The money can be invested and grow tax-free while you decide.

DAFs are easy to open, inexpensive, and allow you to give anonymously. They're especially useful in a high-income year or after selling a business. The tradeoff: the sponsor has final say over grants, and you can't use the fund for anything that benefits you personally, like event tickets.

Private foundation

A separate legal entity your family creates and controls. Foundations offer the most control and permanence. You set the mission, choose the board, can hire staff (including family members, at reasonable pay), and can make grants to individuals or run programs directly.

That control comes with cost and complexity: legal setup, annual tax filings, a requirement to distribute at least 5% of assets each year, a small excise tax on investment income, and public disclosure of grants and finances.

Side by side

Direct givingDonor-advised fundPrivate foundation
SetupNoneMinutes; low minimumsLegal formation; ongoing admin
Control over grantsFullYou recommend; sponsor approvesFull, through your board
Deduction limit, cash60% of AGI60% of AGI30% of AGI
Deduction limit, appreciated stock30% of AGI30% of AGI20% of AGI
Annual payout ruleNoneNone federally5% of assets
PrivacyVariesCan be anonymousPublic tax filings
Family employmentNoNoYes, at reasonable pay

Deduction limits apply to federal itemized deductions; consult your tax advisor about your situation.

Which is right for you?

  • Direct giving works well for modest, straightforward gifts and for close relationships with a few organizations.
  • A donor-advised fund works well for most families who want flexibility, simplicity, and a way to separate the tax decision from the giving decision.
  • A private foundation makes sense for families giving at a large scale who want permanence, full control, and a formal way to involve multiple generations.

Many families use more than one. A DAF for everyday flexibility, direct gifts to longtime partners, and perhaps a foundation for a legacy commitment.

The question behind the question

Vehicles are tools. The real work is deciding what you want your giving to accomplish and who you want to be as a giver. Start there, and bring your wealth manager and attorney in to choose the structure that serves it.

This article is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice. Please consult your own advisors about your situation.

Cite as: Allwell. “Donor-Advised Fund, Private Foundation, or Direct Giving?” Allwell Papers on Philanthropy, no. 4.

Start with a conversation.

Schedule a conversation