Contents
Allwell Papers on PhilanthropyNo. 06

For individuals & families

Beyond the Overhead Ratio: How to Evaluate a Nonprofit

Allwell · Philanthropy Advisory

Abstract

What 500+ leadership searches taught us about which organizations thrive.

For years, donors were told to judge charities by one number: how much goes to "overhead." Lower was better. The problem is that this measure tells you almost nothing about whether an organization works. Starving a nonprofit of the people, systems, and data it needs to do its job is one of the surest ways to make it fail.

We've spent nearly two decades helping more than 350 nonprofits hire their top leaders. That vantage point has taught us what actually separates organizations that thrive from those that drift. Here's what to look at instead.

1. A clear purpose and a theory of change

Can the organization explain, simply, what problem it exists to solve and how its work leads to change? A strong answer connects activities to outcomes: "We do X, which leads to Y, which changes Z." A weak answer lists programs and counts people served.

2. Strong leadership

Leadership is the single best predictor of what an organization will become. Look for a leader who is clear about priorities, honest about challenges, and surrounded by a capable team. Ask about succession: what happens if the executive director leaves? Founder transitions are one of the most vulnerable moments in a nonprofit's life. Much of what made the organization work often lived in one person's head.

3. An engaged, effective board

A good board governs, raises money, asks hard questions, and supports the leader. Ask how often the board meets, how it evaluates the executive director, and whether board members give personally.

4. Honest measurement

The best organizations know whether their work is working, and they'll tell you when it isn't. Ask what they measure, what they've learned, and what they've changed as a result. Be wary of organizations that only share success stories. And remember that measurement should give an organization freedom to experiment, not fear of failure.

5. Financial health

Look at trends, not a single year. Is revenue diversified, or dependent on one funder? Are there reserves to weather a hard year? Is the organization investing in its people and systems, or running on fumes?

6. Signs of drift

Watch for organizations that have started existing for their own sake: growing for growth's sake, chasing whatever funding is available, or keeping programs alive because they always have. Good intentions at the start don't guarantee focus later.

Questions to ask in a site visit

  • What would you do with an unrestricted gift?
  • What's the biggest risk to your work in the next two years?
  • Tell me about a program that didn't work. What did you learn?
  • How is your leadership team changing?
  • What do the people you serve say about you?

Be a partner, not just a funder

Once you've found organizations you believe in, the most valuable thing you can give is trust: multi-year, flexible funding that lets leaders lead. Pair it with honest conversations about results, and you become the kind of donor great organizations hope to find.

This article is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice. Please consult your own advisors about your situation.

Cite as: Allwell. “Beyond the Overhead Ratio: How to Evaluate a Nonprofit” Allwell Papers on Philanthropy, no. 6.

Start with a conversation.

Schedule a conversation